For many years, the NHL entry draft was a significant event for the Ottawa Senators, often feeling like their version of the Stanley Cup. Hope would emerge from the disappointment of missing the playoffs yet again.
However, that sentiment has shifted. After finally breaking their playoff drought, the Senators now hold the 21st overall selection in the upcoming draft.
This new reality in Ottawa means that while the long-term future is certainly of interest, the immediate present holds greater importance for both the fanbase and, to some degree, the organization.
Typically, a team that has just reached the playoffs might see its general manager aggressively pursue players who can make an immediate impact. Yet, the Senators face a limitation: their prospect system is not particularly deep.
Having traded away first-round draft picks for three consecutive years, the team`s prospect pool boasts only one player widely considered elite: Carter Yakemchuk, their seventh overall pick from last year. Adding to this challenge is the impending loss of next year`s first-round pick, a consequence of the poorly executed Evgenii Dadonov trade.
Given this situation, General Manager Steve Staios may find it more prudent to keep the pick and select a promising young player. Nevertheless, Staios maintains that `everything is on the table,` leaving open the possibility that he could trade the pick for an established player like Rasmus Andersson from Calgary or J.J. Peterka from Buffalo.
Speaking of prospects, in Staios`s first draft leading the team last year, all seven players selected by Ottawa were 6-foot-2 or taller. Although Staios stated that size wasn`t the sole criterion for these picks, it will be interesting to observe if this trend continues in the upcoming draft.
If the Senators do utilize the 21st pick, they will likely prioritize selecting the best player available regardless of position. This approach is necessary because Ottawa`s limited talent pipeline means they are not in a position to draft strictly based on organizational needs. An alternative strategy could be for the Senators to trade down from pick 21 to acquire additional draft capital, which they currently lack.
Draft Picks Held:
First (own), Third (via Florida), Fourth (via San Jose), Fifth (own), Sixth (own), Seventh (own)
Potential Round 1 Options at Pick 21:
Jack Nesbitt, C, 6-foot-4, 185 pounds, Windsor Spitfires (OHL)
Our scouting expert Jason Bukala identified Nesbitt as a potentially ideal fit for Ottawa. He is a large forward capable of playing both center and wing, known for his high compete level and effectiveness in front of the net. He is particularly strong in the bumper spot on the power play. Nesbitt scored 25 goals and totaled 64 points for Windsor last season.
Bill Zonnon, C, 6-foot-2, 190 pounds, Blainville-Boisbriand Armada (QMJHL)
Zonnon is a player likely to be available when the Senators pick at 21. Bukala describes him as a “Brady Tkachuk lite,” which would be welcome news for Senators fans. Zonnon is highly competitive, physically imposing, and strong around the net. Similar to Tkachuk, his skating isn`t his strongest asset, but he consistently engages in battles. If his mobility improves, he could become a valuable NHL player.
Blake Fiddler, D, 6-foot-4, 209 pounds, Edmonton Oil Kings (WHL)
Fiddler projects as a shutdown-type defenseman, potentially fitting into a second pairing. He is big, strong, defensively reliable, blocks shots, and is an excellent skater. His father, Vernon Fiddler, played in the NHL. While he may not be a major offensive contributor at the next level, he could become an ideal elite defensive cornerstone for the Senators.
Malcolm Spence, LW, 6-foot-1, 203 pounds, Erie Otters (OHL)
For the Senators seeking a player with high offensive potential, Spence fits the bill. He generates offense through his size, speed, and skill. However, there have been questions regarding his consistency or “motor.” While the Senators have typically favored players with high compete levels, Spence`s best shifts arguably showcase more raw talent than the players mentioned above. He recorded 32 goals and 73 points with Erie last season.
Update on Last Year`s Top Pick: Carter Yakemchuk
Some analysts, including myself, felt Yakemchuk might have been ready to join the Senators right out of training camp last season. However, following his impressive pre-season performance, his play in the Western Hockey League didn`t always meet scout expectations. Despite this, Senators management was reportedly satisfied with his WHL season, and Jason Bukala characterizes him as a “workhorse.” After scoring over a point-per-game in his draft year, Yakemchuk finished last season with 49 points in 56 games for the Calgary Hitmen.
Yakemchuk possesses smooth hands, a strong competitive drive, exceptional strength, and a creative offensive mind highlighted by a powerful shot. However, his skating remains an area needing improvement. He mentioned during training camp last year that refining his skating was a focus.
According to Bukala, another notable weakness in Yakemchuk`s game – keeping in mind he is still only 19 – is his defensive play, particularly five-on-five puck retrievals. Last season, he frequently lost coverage in the defensive zone for a junior player, leading to him not being trusted on the penalty kill by Calgary. If he can develop his defensive capabilities, he has the potential to become an elite NHL defenseman.
Some within the Senators organization believe Yakemchuk could be ready for the NHL and potentially make the team this upcoming season. However, Bukala is skeptical that he is prepared yet. This writer also shares some skepticism. With Nick Jensen`s injury posing a significant question mark, there is an even larger gap on the right side of the Senators` defense corps as it currently stands. The Senators might already regret passing on Zeev Buium, the defenseman selected by the Minnesota Wild who made his NHL debut in the playoffs. Yakemchuk`s development this season and in the future – whether he plays in the American Hockey League or with Ottawa – will be a crucial storyline to follow if the Senators aspire to transition from a good playoff team to a truly great one. No pressure, kid.
